TL;DR
- Schools should have the flexibility to decide when and how AI is used in the classroom.
- AI can help educators save time and personalize learning, but its use should remain a local decision.
- Education technology should support choice, giving districts control over AI adoption, governance, and student experiences.
- As AI evolves, schools need partners that put educational goals, privacy, and educator autonomy first.
In K–12 education, we believe deeply in differentiation, personalization, and student voice and choice. No two learners, classrooms, or communities are exactly alike. Teachers make decisions every day based on the needs of the students in front of them. School leaders adapt to their communities. Districts, departments, and ministries set policies that reflect their priorities, their local context, and their responsibility to the children they serve.
Choice isn’t simply a feature of great education. It’s fundamental to it.
The technology we bring into schools should reflect that same principle.
That’s why Google’s recent announcement regarding AI in Google Workspace for Education deserves a closer look. Starting in early 2027, Gemini and other AI tools will be off by default for K–12 student accounts, which is a welcome step toward giving schools more control. But schools that turn Search on will get it with AI Overviews and AI Mode built in. There is no option for Search without generative AI. A district that wants students searching the web without AI-generated answers has only one alternative: turning Search off entirely.
This is part of a broader pattern of dependencies within Google’s ecosystem. For example, educators who want to create interactive video assignments in Google Classroom must have YouTube enabled by their administrator.
These issues raise a question every education leader should be asking: who should decide when, where, and how AI and other technologies enter the learning experience?
We believe that decision belongs to educators and educational leaders. They’re the ones balancing innovation with student safety, privacy, instructional priorities, and community expectations, and they know their students best.
At D2L, we believe technology should adapt to education, not the other way around.
For more than 25 years, our mission has been to transform the way the world learns. As a founder-led company built around education, we approach technology through the lens of teaching, learning, accessibility, and partnership.
We’re optimistic about AI. Used well, and with appropriate human guidance, it can save teachers time on repetitive tasks so they can focus on what matters most: their students. It can help educators personalize learning. And it can help students become capable, thoughtful users of AI when it’s introduced in the right ways, at the right time, and for the right reasons.
But enthusiasm for AI should never come at the expense of a school’s right to choose.
That’s why our approach is intentional and human-first. With D2L Lumi, the AI built into D2L Brightspace, administrators decide whether it’s available; and D2L Lumi only works when an educator chooses to use it. Layered roles and permissions let you decide who uses which features. And core teaching, learning, and assessment in Brightspace never depend on generative AI.
The same philosophy extends beyond AI. Google Classroom has been a helpful starting point for many schools, offering a simple, familiar place to share assignments and resources. But as districts look to personalize learning, meet compliance requirements, understand student progress, and give teachers back time, many are finding they need more. Brightspace is a full learning management system designed for district-scale goals, bringing course design, assessment, data and reporting, and governance together in one place. It has a low floor for getting started and a high ceiling for growth.
Choosing Brightspace also doesn’t mean giving up the tools teachers already know and love. Schools can keep using Google Drive, Google Docs, and other supported Google workflows, with Brightspace as the foundation for teaching and learning.
This is about more than switching platforms. It’s a chance to rethink what schools should expect from an education technology partner:
- One that respects their autonomy
- One that puts learning ahead of engagement with a technology ecosystem
- One that equips educators with powerful tools and trusts them to decide how to use them
Technology will keep evolving, and AI will keep reshaping education. But the principles behind our decisions should stay constant. District leaders belong in the driver’s seat.
At D2L, we believe the future of K–12 learning belongs to educators, students, and the communities they serve. Our responsibility is to give them the flexibility, capability, and confidence to lead it.
Technology should adapt to education, not the other way around. See how D2L helps K-12 districts support teaching and learning while maintaining choice and control.