Although AI can make learning more responsive to students’ needs and reduce routine faculty work, concerns about inaccurate responses and academic integrity make adoption less straightforward.

This guide examines the pros and cons of AI in education, drawing on higher education research to help you decide whether a tool’s learning benefits justify its risks.

What are the advantages of AI in education?

For colleges and universities, AI can help provide more personalized learning experiences, support students outside class hours, and reduce the time faculty spend preparing course materials. However, these advantages depend on how institutions implement AI and whether its use meaningfully improves teaching and learning.

1. Personalized learning

Two students can complete the same lesson and need very different next steps. One may be ready for a more challenging problem, while the other needs to revisit a concept before moving on. An adaptive learning platform can respond to their performance by adjusting practice difficulty or directing them to relevant course material. These adjustments can make it easier to support students with different needs in large classes.

For example, within D2L Brightspace™, D2L Lumi Study Support can recommend course materials based on students’ incorrect quiz answers, helping them revisit concepts they haven’t yet mastered.

In a randomized controlled trial involving 194 Harvard undergraduate physics students, researchers found that those using a specially designed AI tutor achieved more than double the median learning gains of students receiving in-class active learning instruction. The findings show what this particular tutoring approach achieved in one setting. Other tools still need to be evaluated on their own results.

2. Immediate feedback and on-demand student support

A student may understand a concept during a lecture but struggle to apply it when studying alone. An AI tutor can respond to questions outside class hours, allowing students to work through a difficult step while the material is still fresh.

The feedback needs to be accurate and reliable, particularly when students cannot immediately verify an explanation with an instructor.

As you evaluate how well this support works, consider your students’ perspectives on AI in education alongside assessment results to see whether students are finding the guidance useful and where they still need your help.

3. Reduced educator workload and faster course development

Drafting practice activities and assessments takes time, especially when you’re adapting existing course materials for a new term or a different group of students. AI can help by generating questions from a reading or lecture notes you’ve already prepared. You can then select and refine the questions that match what students are expected to learn.

However, AI-generated questions can misrepresent concepts, introduce information that isn’t supported by the source material, or test the wrong level of understanding. You’ll still need to review them for clarity, relevance, and alignment with your learning objectives before students see them.

Create course content with D2L Lumi
Turn existing materials into draft modules and quiz questions you can review before publishing.
Explore D2L Lumi

4. Earlier identification of students who need support

In a large class, the early signs that a student is falling behind can go unnoticed.

Someone who usually submits work on time may begin missing weekly quizzes or participating less in course activities. By showing changes in engagement and performance over time, automated learning analytics can help you identify students who may need support before a major assessment.

These insights give you a reason to review what’s happening and reach out to the student. From there, you can consider their circumstances and decide whether additional academic support is needed.

5. Greater accessibility for diverse learners

AI can make course materials more accessible by generating captions for recorded lectures and helping convert readings into formats students can listen to or use with assistive technology. 

Captions help students who are deaf or hard of hearing follow spoken explanations, while audio versions of readings can support students with visual impairments, dyslexia, or other learning disabilities. Having different formats available gives students more ways to engage with course content according to their needs.

Automated captions can misrepresent technical terms, and converted documents may lose the structure screen readers rely on. You’ll still need to review the outputs to make sure students can use them effectively.

What are the disadvantages of AI in education?

Alongside its many benefits, AI also presents risks that can affect students’ learning and how institutions make academic decisions.

The safeguards you need will depend on the tool’s purpose and the consequences of getting it wrong.

1. Academic integrity and assessment challenges

Because generative AI can produce complete answers to assignments, students may submit work they haven’t written themselves. This makes it harder to assess their understanding and determine whether their grades reflect what they’ve learned.

Among 1,054 full-time UK undergraduates surveyed by HEPI, 94% said they used generative AI to help with assessed work. The proportion directly including AI-generated text in assessed work increased from 3% in 2024 to 8% in 2025 and 12% in 2026. With that level of use, general warnings about cheating leave too much open to interpretation.

An institutional academic integrity policy can set common expectations, but each assignment needs clear instructions on permitted AI assistance and disclosure. If you’re assessing independent reasoning, ask students to explain how they reached their conclusions and evaluate that work against a rubric aligned with your learning objectives. When you suspect misconduct, review the submission in context rather than treating an AI detector’s result as proof.

Those expectations may change depending on what the assignment asks students to do:

Student AI activityWhat institutions need to clarify
Using AI to explain a difficult conceptWhether AI-assisted studying is permitted
Using AI to create assignment outlines or draftsWhich stages of work AI can support, how much of the final draft must be the student’s original work, and how students should disclose AI use 
Submitting AI-generated answersWhich assessments allow AI-generated content in the final submission, and how academic integrity policies treat unapproved use

💡Important: Using generative AI in assessed work isn’t automatically academic misconduct. Whether it breaches the rules depends on the assessment requirements and institutional policies.

2. Inaccurate content and feedback

An AI-generated explanation can sound convincing even when it gets a concept wrong. Students who rely on it may carry the misunderstanding into their assignments, particularly when the feedback they receive reinforces an incorrect approach.

The same risk applies when you use AI to develop course materials or assessments. A fabricated reference in a reading guide or an incorrect quiz question can mislead an entire class. These limitations of AI-assisted course design make it important to verify claims against credible sources and check that generated materials reflect your learning objectives before students see them.

3. Overreliance on AI and weaker independent thinking

Although AI can help students understand difficult material, relying on it for every answer may leave them with fewer chances to think through problems on their own. 

When a student replaces a challenging reading with an AI summary or lets a chatbot complete an exercise, they can miss the reasoning and analysis the activity was designed to develop.

You can curb the risks by introducing:

  • Practice questions, such as those available in D2L Lumi Tutor, can help students test their understanding if you ask them to attempt an answer before consulting AI feedback
  • Requiring students to explain their reasoning or apply a concept to a new problem gives them a reason to engage with the material rather than simply accept a generated response

4. Algorithmic bias and unfair outcomes

AI systems can reflect biases in the data used to train them, which may affect how they evaluate students. 

For example, a grading tool trained largely on one variety of academic English might assign different scores to equally strong essays written in other varieties. Similar biases could influence the feedback students receive or lead to unfair predictions about who needs academic support.

To address AI bias, test how a tool evaluates comparable student work across groups and investigate unexplained differences. Review AI-generated feedback against your assessment criteria, and retain human oversight of decisions about grades and student support.

5. Student data privacy and security risks

Using AI for coursework can expose information that would otherwise stay within your institution’s systems. A student might paste an assignment into a chatbot, or you might upload assessment submissions to generate feedback. 

Depending on the tool, that information could be shared without authorization, accessed by people who shouldn’t see it, or retained longer than expected. Student records and course materials may be at risk as well.

These data privacy concerns make it important to vet each AI application before allowing it to handle institutional information. Even a tool with security protections may have data-sharing or retention practices that don’t meet your requirements.

💡Before approving an AI tool
Confirm who owns and controls submitted data, whether student information is used to train AI models, and where it’s stored. Ask who can access it, how long it’s retained, and what safeguards and deletion options the vendor provides.

6. Unequal access to AI tools

When an assignment requires a paid AI tool, students who can’t afford the subscription may be at a disadvantage before they begin. Even free tools depend on reliable internet, a suitable device, and the skills to use AI effectively. These differences can affect students’ ability to complete the same coursework under comparable conditions.

Providing approved AI tools through your institution’s learning platform can reduce reliance on personal subscriptions and offer more consistent access. However, institution-wide adoption brings licensing and support costs, and access alone won’t resolve gaps in connectivity or AI literacy.

Your plans should include faculty AI training so instructors can guide students in using the tools responsibly and offer alternatives when access remains a barrier.

7. Reduced student-faculty interaction

When AI tutors and automated feedback become a student’s main source of academic support, instructors may have fewer chances to see where that student is struggling. 

A chatbot can answer a question in seconds, but the student may still need a conversation to work through a persistent misunderstanding. 

Without that contact, they lose opportunities for the personalized guidance and mentorship that help deepen their learning.

To keep those opportunities open, ensure your AI tool of choice allows for routine study questions and practice activities, leaving instructors more time to work directly with students when they need deeper guidance. 

This helps preserve the human element in AI for higher ed while keeping teaching, feedback, and academic decisions in educators’ hands.

Keep educators in control of AI-generated content
D2L Lumi draws on existing course materials to generate draft learning resources you can review and refine before students access them.

How can higher education institutions weigh the pros and cons of AI?

Now that we’ve examined AI’s advantages and disadvantages, here’s how to weigh the trade-offs when deciding whether to adopt AI at your institution and, if so, which tools to use and how widely to make them available.

The table below compares common AI applications, the educational value they may offer, and what you should assess before making a decision.

AI applicationPotential educational valueMain risk to evaluateWhat institutions should assess
AI tutoringPersonalized instruction and timely supportInaccurate explanations or overrelianceEvidence of learning gains and opportunities for independent thinking
AI-assisted course developmentFaster preparation of learning materialsInaccurate or poorly aligned contentInstructional quality, learning objective alignment, and instructor review
AI-supported assessmentFaster assessment preparation and feedbackAcademic integrity concerns or unfair evaluationAssessment validity, transparency, and human oversight
Predictive learning analyticsEarlier identification of students needing supportBias or misuse of personal informationPredictive accuracy, fairness, and data protection

The Harvard physics trial discussed earlier shows the value of measuring learning gains rather than relying on claims about speed or engagement. Its findings apply to a particular tutor and setting, so you’ll still need evidence that the tool you’re considering works for your students.

When evaluating a pilot, check whether students can apply what they’ve learned without AI assistance. Time savings may be useful, but they don’t establish that learning has improved.

The results should also inform how much responsibility you give the tool. AI tutors can support independent practice, while recommendations that could affect grades or student support should be reviewed by instructors. The greater the consequences of an error, the more important human oversight becomes.

Institutional policy should make these boundaries clear without imposing identical rules on every course. A 2026 Delphi study involving 35 higher education experts from 22 countries and locations found that 88% favored pairing formal policies with flexible guidelines. That expert preference supports an approach to AI governance in higher education in which institutions approve tools and set data-use rules, while instructors determine acceptable AI assistance in their assessments. 

Balancing AI adoption with educational priorities

The case for AI in higher education rests on what students gain from it. Where a tool improves learning and its risks can be managed, adoption may make sense. 

Where the evidence is weak or safeguards aren’t sufficient, institutions can limit its use rather than introduce it across every learning activity. Ultimately, the priority should be improving educational outcomes while preserving the human judgment that effective teaching requires.

Explore AI-enabled teaching and learning with Brightspace

See how Brightspace and D2L Lumi can support course development and student learning while keeping educators in control. Explore how these capabilities align with your institution’s educational goals.

Book a personalized demo.>

Frequently asked questions about the pros and cons of AI in education

What is an AI-enabled learning management system?

An AI-enabled learning management system (LMS) includes AI-enabled features that help instructors prepare materials or support student learning within their existing platform.

How much does it cost to implement AI in higher education?

Costs depend on licensing fees, user numbers, and whether your LMS includes AI features. Budget for faculty training and ongoing support alongside subscriptions.

What is the difference between generative AI and adaptive learning?

Generative AI creates content from prompts, while adaptive learning adjusts activities based on student performance to personalize the learning experience. The former is useful for creating learning materials, generating practice questions, and providing explanations. Adaptive learning is better suited to identifying knowledge gaps and adjusting the difficulty or sequence of activities to match individual student needs.

Why do faculty struggle to adopt AI tools in higher education?

Faculty may lack time to assess unfamiliar tools or doubt their educational value. Hands-on AI training and clear institutional guidance can help.

Can AI tools integrate with an existing learning management system?

Yes. Some AI tools can connect to existing LMS platforms through Learning Tools Interoperability (LTI), a standard that allows external learning applications to work with an LMS. Before implementation, confirm compatibility and ensure the integration meets your institution’s student data privacy and security requirements.

How can universities use AI to improve student advising?

Predictive analytics can flag students who may need academic support based on their coursework or participation. Advisers should review these signals personally before deciding whether to intervene.

Table of Contents

  1. What are the advantages of AI in education?
  2. What are the disadvantages of AI in education?
  3. How can higher education institutions weigh the pros and cons of AI?
  4. Balancing AI adoption with educational priorities